WHAT HAPPENS NEXT

is off the record

“Behind every one of our great bottles is a better story—and in our members-only society, you get both. Rooted in the legacy of a historic hotel and the spirit of speakeasies past, you’ll enjoy exclusive pours and behind-the-scenes access to the team behind Tarnished Truth.”

andrew yancey
President & Founder of Tarnished Truth Distilling Company
member benefits overview

Members find out… the good stuff's in the back.

our finest bourbon

Receive four bottles of our most exquisite creations, including members-only single barrel picks and unique finishes. Additionally, skip-the-line to purchase select distillery exclusives releases before the general public.

unprecedented access

Attend exclusive gatherings that revive the spirit of so many unforgettable nights—including complimentary pours in the Hunt Room and exclusive single barrel tastings.

a seat at the table

The Cavalier Club is tailored to your tastes. Influence everything from the event calendar to our bourbon by participating in annual members-only Town Halls to make your voice heard.

Your Evenings, Revealed

Step into a world of unmatched exclusivity, with privileged access to Virginia Beach’s most sought-after events—all within the heart of the city’s ultimate destination for opulence.
July 12, 2025

The Cavalier Club Welcome Event

Indulge in two expertly crafted cocktails alongside two premium pours. Mix and mingle with fellow members over hors d'oeuvres as you get a first look at the exclusive experience we’ve planned and the remarkable benefits that come with joining The Cavalier Club by Tarnished Truth Distilling Company.

What to Expect
  • Receive and wax-dip your inaugural member bottle, a members-only release of Tarnished Truth Discretion Honey Cask Finished Bourbon
  • Your say, your sip: vote on the first Hunt Room cocktail made exclusively for members
  • Unwind at our dedicated cigar table, presented in collaboration with Emerson’s Cigars and featuring a handpicked selection of fine cigars available for purchase
September 1, 2025
September 13, 2025 (Recurring)

The Hunt Room Speakeasy Series

Join fellow members at the Hunt Room bar for an intimate evening of cocktails and conversation. Enjoy specialty drinks featuring Discretion, Old Cavalier, and High Rye bourbon while Andrew Yancey shares behind-the-scenes stories of launching Tarnished Truth and the rich history that inspired it.

Firsthand Insights

Go behind the scenes with Master Distiller Justin Boyle as he offers a candid look into the distillation process—from grain to glass—that gives Tarnished Truth its unmistakable character.

‍

Our Speakeasy Series will be held multiple times throughout the year with curated themes for each event.

November 7, 2025
November 7, 2025

The Cavalier Club VBI Party

The evening before the Virginia Bourbon Invitational, join fellow members in the Hunt Room for a special celebration of our shared love of bourbon—and to collect your bottle of Tarnished Truth Discretion PX Sherry Cask Finished Bourbon.

What to Expect
  • Collect your release of Tarnished Truth Discretion PX Sherry Cask Finished Bourbon
  • Your say, your sip: vote on the next Hunt Room cocktail, made exclusively for members

‍

January 1, 2026
January 2026

The Bootlegger’s Selection

In the shadow of Prohibition, bootleggers once risked everything to move uncut, barrel-strength spirits through hidden channels—sharing their finest with only a select few. That spirit of rebellion, quality, and exclusivity lives on in this unforgettable evening at the historic Cavalier Hotel. In this storied setting, members will take part in a rare opportunity: selecting a single barrel expression of our Tarnished Truth 3 Year High Rye Barrel Strength, to be bottled exclusively for our community.

What to Expect
  • Welcome cocktail & curated small bites
  • Guided tasting of exclusive barrel samples
  • A members-only single-barrel selection
  • Your say, your sip: vote on the next Hunt Room cocktail, made exclusively for members
March 1, 2026
March 2026

The Hidden Cask Hunting Party

Some casks are meant to rest longer than others—tucked away in the quietest corners, gathering depth, richness, and character with every passing season. After seven years of patient aging, one such barrel is ready to emerge. Together in our Hunt Room, we’ll sample from hidden casks of exceptional Old Cavalier bourbon—deep with buttery toffee that coats the mouth, and hints of black pepper and cinnamon—and select one for bottling, exclusively for members.

What to Expect
  • Welcome cocktail and elevated hors d'oeuvres
  • A guided tasting of aged whiskey straight from the barrel
  • Discussion on long-term aging and the alchemy of oak
  • A members-only single-barrel selection
  • Your say, your sip: vote on the next Hunt Room cocktail, made exclusively for members
June 18, 2027
June 2026

Coming Soon

We're working on something special for you and will announce the details once they're available.

What to Expect
  • Receive your members-only bottle of Old Cavalier Single Barrel Bourbon
  • Your say, your sip: vote on the next Hunt Room cocktail, made exclusively for members
for members only

Guaranteed access to the legendary VBI

Sold out in under 5 minutes last year. Don’t miss your chance this time to sip and savor bourbons from over twenty top-tier distilleries.
Priority Ticket Access to the Virginia Bourbon Invitational

Enjoy guaranteed access to purchase a General Admission or VIP ticket to one of our state’s most legendary events—the Virginia Bourbon Invitational, which sold out in under five minutes last year.

All tickets include tastings, food from some of the area’s best restaurants, access to a cash bar, access to the cigar bar and lounge, and live music throughout the event.

VIP tickets provide guests with exclusive early entry one hour before general admission, giving you an intimate opportunity to discover your next favorite pour.

Your Bottles, Exposed

As part of your journey in The Cavalier Club, you will receive our most exclusive bottles—not available to the public. The best that we can create is reserved for this most select group.

*Due to the nature of the aging process, exact bottles are subject to change to ensure The Cavalier Club members have access to our premium standard of spirits.

July 2025

Tarnished Truth Discretion Honey Cask Finished Bourbon

This 4-year wheated bourbon is finished in honey casks for two months, imparting notes of spiced honey, toffee, and mild oak. Smooth and gently layered, it offers a comforting sweetness balanced by subtle depth.

‍

At the inaugural members-only event, each bottle will be hand-dipped in wax by members and sealed with the official Cavalier Club emblem — making every bottle a personal keepsake. This special release is exclusive to members and will not be available to the public. One bottle is included per membership, with the option to purchase more while supplies last.

age:
4 years
proof:
90
bottle:
750ml
november 2025

Tarnished Truth Discretion PX Sherry Cask Finished Bourbon

Finished in rich Pedro Ximénez sherry casks, this single-barrel bourbon is closely monitored by Head Distiller Justin Boyle — first sampled two weeks into the finishing process, then tasted every few days until the perfect balance is struck. The PX cask imparts a natural sweetness and layered depth, rounding out the pour with warmth and a lingering, velvety finish.

‍

This special release is exclusive to members and will not be available to the public. One bottle is guaranteed per member, with the option to purchase more while supplies last.

age:
4 years
proof:
90
bottle:
750ml
march 2026

Tarnished Truth High Rye Single Barrel Bourbon

Bold yet beautifully balanced, this is the only barrel strength offering at Tarnished Truth Distillery—and this particular single barrel will be selected by members of The Cavalier Club during an exclusive tasting event. This release will not be available to the public and cannot be purchased anywhere else.

‍

Expect a high-proof pour that doesn’t sacrifice finesse: waves of toasted oak and honeyed vanilla open the palate, followed by a warming blend of clove and cinnamon spice.

‍

age:
3 years
proof:
115
bottle:
375ml
June 2026

Old Cavalier Single Barrel Bourbon

Pulled from Tarnished Truth’s most time-honored line, this special release will be a single barrel selected by Cavalier Club members during an upcoming event.

‍

Aged 7 years, this single barrel promises the signature depth and richness Old Cavalier is known for—layered notes of buttery toffee, warming spice, and mellow oak. Bottled exclusively for members, it’s a well-aged pour that lingers long after each sip.

age:
7 years
proof:
TBD
bottle:
750ml
VIP ACCESS

Know the knock that unlocks VIP distillery benefits

$120 in Hunt Room Credits

Receive a $120 credit ($30 quarterly) to use in the Hunt Room on food and beverages, including members-only cocktails. Quarterly credits expire at the end of each quarter and do not roll over.

60% off Hunt Room Private Bookings

Receive 60% off private bookings (regularly $250) for your personal events and enjoy early access to exclusive bourbon dinners.

Exclusive Member Pours

Anytime you visit the Hunt Room, you can claim a complimentary pour reserved for members of The Cavalier Club, while quarterly allocations remain available.

Free Tour Tickets

Enjoy a complimentary tour ticket with your visit to the distillery. Please note, tickets must be booked in advance.

Retail Store Discount

Get a 10% off discount on merchandise featured in our retail store (excluding alcohol).

FOR FOUNDING MEMBERS ONLY

YOUR NAME ON A BARREL — YOUR LEGACY IN THE GLASS

an exclusive honor available only to the inaugural members of The Cavalier Club.
Your Name on Display + Your Barrel in the Making

Founding Members of The Cavalier Club will be permanently recognized with their name signed on a commemorative barrel head, proudly displayed in the Tarnished Truth tasting room.

They will also join Master Distiller Justin Boyle to select the mash bill and fill a one-of-a-kind barrel during a private member experience. Once matured, each Founding Member will receive a bottle of the final release—along with the exclusive right to purchase any remaining bottles—available only while their membership remains active.

Become a Founding member

2025 membership Options
Individual Plan
Membership for one person
‍
$299
per quarter, or $999 per year
Save $197 when paying annually.
Save $197 when paying annually.
what's included
4 members-only bottles a year, for pick-up at the distillery
Members-only in-person and virtual events throughout the year
Early access to purchase distillery-exclusive
bottle releases
$120 credit ($30 quarterly) to use in the Hunt Room on food and beverages
60% off private bookings (regularly $250) at the Hunt Room
1 vote during society town hall virtual events
Unlimited free distillery tours
Quarterly members-only cocktail available for purchase
10% off merchandise at our retail store (excludes alcohol)
Guaranteed general admission or VIP ticket purchase opportunity to the Virginia Bourbon Invitational
what's included
family Plan
Great for couples or pairs of friends. Additional member must be 21+ years old.
$425
per quarter, or $1499 per year
Save $201 when paying annually.
Save $201 when paying annually.
what's included
4 members-only bottles a year, for pick-up at the distillery
Members-only in-person and virtual events throughout the year for two members
Early access to purchase distillery-exclusive bottle releases for both members
$120 credit ($30 quarterly) to use in the Hunt Room on food and beverages
60% off private bookings (regularly $250) at the Hunt Room
2 votes during society town hall virtual events
Unlimited free distillery tours for two members
Quarterly members-only cocktail available for purchase
10% off merchandise at our retail store (excludes alcohol)
Guaranteed general admission or VIP ticket purchase opportunity to the Virginia Bourbon Invitational for two members
what's included
BEGIN ENROLLMENT
ENROLLMENT CLOSED
ENROLLMENT CLOSED
Enrollment for the current period is now full.
If you haven’t already, click below to apply for our next enrollment period. We will notify you as soon as spots open for new members.
apply now
FAQ’s
how do i get an invitation code?

You can apply for an invitation code at: www.thecavalierclub.vip/apply

what is The Cavalier Club?

The Cavalier Club is an exclusive, members-only community designed for the most passionate Tarnished Truth bourbon enthusiasts. Members gain access to rare and limited-edition bourbons, exclusive events, behind-the-scenes experiences, and unique insights. More than just a membership, it is a journey into the heart of our distillery—where members become part of our inner circle and celebrate the craft of bourbon.

What does membership include?

Joining The Cavalier Club is more than just a membership—it’s a way for customers to deepen their connection to Tarnished Truth and elevate their bourbon experience. Members can expect to enjoy:

‍

Rare and exclusive bottles

An annual membership includes four bottles of Tarnished Truth’s most sought-after bourbons, created or handpicked just for members. These bottles represent some of our finest and most innovative creations, carefully curated to offer a unique tasting experience with each release. It’s our way of bringing the best of Tarnished Truth into members homes, ensuring you always have something exceptional to enjoy.

‍

Invitations to members-only events

Members will be invited to a variety of exclusive events, both in-person and online, designed to deepen their connection with Tarnished Truth. From educational experiences with Head Distiller Justin Boyle and behind-the-scenes experiences to exclusive tasting sessions and special release previews, these events offer unique opportunities to immerse themselves in the world of bourbon. Each experience is crafted to inspire a lifetime of memories, giving members a chance to savor the finest Tarnished Truth has to offer and be a part of our close-knit community.

‍

Exclusive distillery access and benefits

Members enjoy a range of exclusive privileges designed to enhance their connection to Tarnished Truth. From priority access to limited releases and special events to complimentary experiences and members-only perks, these benefits ensure a deeper, more immersive journey into the world of bourbon. Whether visiting the distillery or engaging from afar, members receive unique opportunities to experience the legacy, craftsmanship, and hospitality that define The Cavalier Club.

How do the membership options differ?

Family Membership

  • Includes membership for two people (one primary member plus one additional member).
  • Always grants access for two people at events.
  • Includes one carefully selected bottle per quarter, shared between both members.
  • Opportunity to purchase up to two distillery-exclusive releases per quarter* (one per member).
  • Unlimited free distillery tours for two people (when booked in advance).
  • Two votes during society town hall virtual events.
  • Guaranteed opportunity to purchase two general admission or VIP tickets to the Virginia Bourbon Invitational.

Individual Membership

  • Designed for one person only.
  • Option to purchase a plus-one ticket for select events, based on availability.
  • Includes one carefully selected bottle per quarter.
  • Opportunity to purchase one distillery-exclusive release per quarter*.
  • One vote during society town hall virtual events.
  • Unlimited free distillery tours for one person (when booked in advance).
  • Guaranteed opportunity to purchase one general admission or VIP ticket to the Virginia Bourbon Invitational.

*Based on allocations

Both memberships include one membership kit with the initial enrollment along with one new bottle each quarter to enjoy.

Can I bring a guest to events?

For select events (subject to availability), members may purchase plus-one tickets for $99 each.

  • Individual Plan members may purchase up to 1 guest ticket.
  • Family Plan members may purchase up to 2 guest tickets.
Do I have to pay for the bottles included in membership?

No, members don’t have to pay for the bottles included in the membership. As a member of The Cavalier Club, members will receive exclusive and unique bottles each quarter as part of their membership benefits—these are covered by their annual membership dues. Additionally, as a member, they will be among the first to know about special bottle releases before they are announced to the general public. While these special releases are available for purchase, member’s early access ensures they have the first opportunity to secure them.

How long will my bottle be held if I don’t pick it up?

There is a 90-day window to pick up your bottle in person.

‍

For members in states where shipping is allowed, we’ll send a reminder before that window closes. If the bottle remains unclaimed, your subscription will be automatically updated to include the shipping option, and your card on file will be charged accordingly.

‍

If you live in a no-shipping state, we reserve the right to cancel your membership and issue a prorated refund if the bottles have not been claimed after 90 days.

Are all states eligible for bottle shipping?

Due to varying state laws, members residing in Virginia, or in South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, or Utah, are required to pick up their bottles in person. Members in all other U.S. states may choose to have their bottles shipped for an additional fee.

‍

If you live in a no-shipping state and are required to pick up your bottles in-person, they will be held at the distillery for 90 days from the date of your pickup notification. After 90 days, if the bottles have not been claimed, we reserve the right to cancel your membership and issue a prorated refund.

Can I change my membership?

Membership changes

You can change your membership from Individual to Family, and vice versa, based upon availability. Please just email our concierge team: concierge@thecavalierclub.vip

‍

Membership cancellations

Membership can be canceled at any time, no questions asked. Members on the annual payment plan will receive a prorated refund for the remaining period of their subscription. For members on the quarterly payment plan, membership remains active until the end of the quarter and will not be charged for following quarters.

‍

Membership transfers

Memberships cannot be transferred to anyone else.

Can my plus one purchase a bottle?

Depending on availability, members’ plus ones will be able to purchase an additional bottle at each member event. These must be purchased on-site and cannot be shipped.